Hey ya'll!
I just got back from Floyfest and let me tell you it was fun. If you've never been to a camp in style music festival this is a good one for a first timer. It's got a great low stress vibe, smallish crowds and an overall family atmosphere.
Back to the business of laying some common sense, as I see it, on the masses. Or at least the handful of people, ok two handfuls, that read this rag of a blog. By the way, I can actually earn enough money to buy a tank of gas in a year of enough people read this thing, so please share.
It seems that a certain chain of chicken restaurants have come under fire as of late because of their Christian based values. My Facebook news feed has been inundated with comments, posts and pics about the Chic-fiasco. Unless you've been under a rock lately you already know that the CEO is a staunch advocate of not allowing same sex marriages. You can find the whole story here on their website at The Devil!!
What?
You clicked on the link and there was no gay bashing?
No political or philosophical speeches?
MY GOD!!!!
No wait!!
There were no links to biblical sites?
What do you mean it had advertisements for their food???
They have the gall to post menus and store locations?
The NERVE of this restaurant to so openly criticize how other people live!!!!!!!!!!
But they don't, their CEO does.
For as long as I can remember this restaurant has been closed on Sunday and has never hidden the fact their business principles are based in Christian values. No one should be surprised that the founders are opposed to same sex marriage. So while this is suddenly an issue I want to ask if you ate there before all this got stirred up? Or did you really just think they wanted Sundays off to go fishing?
If I'm reading things on Facebook correctly I should either choose NOT to buy a chicken sandwich because I support same sex marriage or I SHOULD buy a chicken sandwich because I don't support same sex marriage.
If I am to apply this manner of decision making to my everyday life I will need a list of all restaurants I may ever buy food from and their CEO's political beliefs. I want to know exactly how the owner of any company I choose to support with my money will spend his or her profits.
I want to be able to base my spending decisions not on what I want or need but how the money I spend is then redistributed by the owners of that company. I need to know if they support same sex marriage, who they voted for in the last election, who they will vote for in this election, how they pray, if they pray...
Wait?
You say I'm being silly?
You say I'm overstating what's going on here?
Yeah, maybe, but it's a slippery slope. How much do you need to know when you spend your money? If restaurants are to be painted blue and red to show which way their owners lean politically I want to align myself with the purple restaurants right now.
I get that it's an election year. I get that everyone has an opinion. But here is a little newsflash for all of us. No one agrees with you, me, on everything. You're going to be hard pressed to find a restaurant, store or other vendor who has an owner who agrees with you on same sex marriage AND gun control AND abortion AND...
Get the point?
What I WILL say is that if Chic Fil A or any other entity openly discriminates against any group that you should boycott them. However, Christine Romans of CNN's Starting Point made this statement in a conversation with a Chicago City Alderman "We at CNN have not substantiated any of these claims about the company actually in its hiring or serving practices putting this into — using anything discriminatory."
Link to the conversation mentioned CNN's Starting point
I've not done the data mining, but I'll trust CNN to not miss a beat if they do find any evidence of discrimination.
I admire the Mayor of Boston for speaking out on this subject. However I can't help but disagree with his tactics. It's all well and good when the government opposes something you agree with. But be warned, if you allow it to begin to pick and choose who does what based on philosophy rather than law you're on a slippery slope. All it takes is one election for all the things you support to that which is under fire.
So what do I think?
I support civil rights for everyone. The LGBT community is nothing that comes to my mind on any sort of regular basis. The only time someones sexuality comes to my mind is when it applies to whether or not I want to ask them out.
Otherwise, when I'm looking for fast food I only need to know two things:
1. Did the cook wash his hands?
2. Can I super-size it?
A friend of mine tried to comment but lacks an account here.
ReplyDeleteThis was her response to the link posted on Facebook.
"I tried to comment but I have to sign in and whatnot so no thanks. It's not news to me and as a result I have not given that chicken place any of my money in quite some time. The guy has a right to his own opinion, sure, but he's not going to use any of my money to back that agenda. Further, yes, some people do try to research where their money might go after it's spent. I do, sometimes, when I have time and I'm motivated. Additionally, I'm less than thrilled about the politics of that tomato and cheese pie place where I'm employed but ain't nobody payin' the bills but me so maybe that makes me a hypocrite. Soooo You do what you want for your own reasons and I'll do what I want for mine."
I agree with most of what was said, but not necessarily how it was all applied.
ReplyDeleteIf we are going to use a slippery slope argument about paying attention to what CEO's of companies do with their money, is it not also permissible to use the slippery slope argument about customers allowing CEO's to siphon off profits to oppress a minority?
I noticed in every debate on the topic I've seen, the people in favor of Chick-Fil-A or indifferent tend to think the problem we have with Chick-Fil-A is their belief. And that's probably true. It is not their beliefs that make me not eat at Chick-Fil-A. It is their actions.
Hypothetically, if the CEO of payless shoes were funding skinheads and Nazi's, would you take action? What if they used profits to fund terrorists? If that is all irrelevant to you, then so be it. If you would find any of those relevant, than you are acting the same way that people did in Nazi Germany.
"First they came for the communists,
and I didn't speak out because I wasn't a communist.
Then they came for the trade unionists,
and I didn't speak out because I wasn't a trade unionist.
Then they came for the Jews,
and I didn't speak out because I wasn't a Jew.
Then they came for me
and there was no one left to speak out for me."
Supporting civil rights for everyone involves actually supporting them. It's not sticking a bumper sticker on your car. There is a list out there from the LGBT community of companies that are oppressive to gay people. They all have alternative companies that supply the same things at about the same cost. It's all really easy to do.
Another big takeaway from this whole thing is that it is claimed that it is a Christian value. Not all Christians would agree, so yes, it's perfectly reasonable to be shocked by this.
To clarify, people who attack Chick-Fil-A are also against the CEO's beliefs. That's inherent in taking that stance. So many of them are trying to attack the idea first and foremost, even though what they really want to come out of the boycott is the actions that stem from the ideas to stop.
ReplyDeleteThey also want the idea to stop too, but that's simply unrealistic.
That's an interesting argument. However I think what while your heart is in the right place in application you may fall short.
ReplyDeletethere is no litmus test for support of a cause. Support of a cause begins with believing in it and if that's as far as you get than so be it. That's more than enough. If you're inclined to put a bumper sticker on your car than that's even better. Perhaps someone will see that bumper sticker and be inclined to take a moment or two to reflect on their own beliefs on the subject. Now we are going somewhere.
But boycotting a business does nothing for a cause. Unless you can effectively shut it down with the boycott, a strike of sorts, you won't affect any real change. You're protest will be anecdotal at best.
If you want to affect change you have to win hearts and minds and you can't do that from afar. You have to go to the belly of the beast.
Follow this link: https://www.facebook.com/events/444598242237116/
That is my idea of protest.
Rosa Parks didn't change history by staying off the bus, she changed history by sitting in front.
http://www.thefreedictionary.com/support
ReplyDeleteI'll grant that tolerate is a definition listed there, but I don't think you meant you tolerate gays.
http://www.ethicalconsumer.org/boycotts/successfulboycotts.aspx
Wise men realize that the best way to win hearts and minds is to get them when they are young. I've rarely seen any success any other way, with the exception of when people are desperate.
The Ethical Consumer is a nice page. I don't see, and am not going to start digging through corporate financials to validate this statement, that the boycotts had so much of an economic impact as a publicity impact.
ReplyDeleteOf course the argument that the publicity aspect turned in to a financial impact is valid.
But this isn't about merino wool or sweatshops. It's about civil rights and civil rights have hardly been won through boycotts. A quick glance at the civil rights movement of the 60's have hardly anything to do with the inaction of a boycott but rather the action of protest.
Homophobia, in my opinion, is the result of ignorance. It stems from a lack of exposure. I was raised to fear homosexuals and until I was exposed to, and befriended by, homosexuals did I learn to be indifferent to their sexuality as I am that of other heterosexuals such as myself.
If Chick fil-A wants to become a bastion of "Christian" values and homophobia I encourage those who oppose the ideas to swarm the place. To take it over and turn it into a Mecca of acceptance rather than a refuge for those fearful of that which they don't understand.
It took only a handful of German soldiers to march thousands of Jews to the Death Camps in WW2. Why? Why when thousands could have easily overrun so few solders and then been free? Because they chose to abstain from action. To me, a boycott is abstaining from action. It's taking your ball home because others won't play by your rules.
I'd rather see you stay and play and win by their rules than avoid the game altogether.
As far as that definition of support goes I don't see any sort of minimum requirements that need to be met. Telling someone, or implying that, they are not doing enough when they are doing all they can is an easy way to talk them into doing nothing.
I get it, I really do, where you're coming from. But I'm much more of an in your face lets deal with it kind of guy. Get the fight over with, push through, endure and overcome.
I'll leave it at that and any response you want to give. This has been a good debate and is VERY healthy. I appreciate your responses and hope you comment on blogs in the future.
Interestingly enough, my research into boycotts indicates that Chick-Fil-A is not a company that a boycott will affect enough to change their actions.
ReplyDeleteDeciding to boycott Chick-Fil-A anyway reminds me of my decision to vote third party. If everybody knew that a 3rd party candidate could become president, then it might happen. For the individual, your actions have no real independent effect on the outcome. Better to choose the lesser of two evils then, right?
If everybody knew that their boycott of Chick-Fil-A would have an impact, then maybe it would (depending on the real level of support the population has for gay marriage).
Knowing that our imperfect knowledge creates a self fulfilling prophecy inclines me to act in such a way that if everyone followed suit, we would break the cycle. Power to the people!
Thanks for the open forum and for not mistaking my words as venomous in any way.